Sovereignty in IT
- 547 wordsAs the USA becomes increasingly authoritarian, the question becomes more important: How independent are we in Europe from the USA? Large parts of the internet run on servers operated by AWS, Google, Cloudflare, Microsoft, and others. These are US-companies, and even if the servers are located in Europe, USA authorities may be able to gain access to the data (as Microsoft admitted). Using software from European vendors doesn’t necessarily provide protection, because they often use servers from AWS, Google, etc., as well, and therefore USA authorities have access again.
But is there really a risk? There are at least a few cases:
-
The Chief Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC), Karim Ahmad Khan, was sanctioned by the USA in early 2025. As a result, he lost access to his Microsoft email account.
-
French ICC Judge Nicolas Guillou was sanctioned by the United States in August 2025. Following that, companies from the USA such as Amazon, Airbnb, and PayPal closed his accounts. Online payments have become virtually impossible for him.
-
The German ticket retailer ProTicket was cut off by PayPal because it sold tickets for the musical Soy de Cuba as well as concerts by Cuban artists. (Netzpolitik)
How independent are we?
- Just because you use a service provided by a German company doesn’t necessarily mean you’re independent. Often, these companies also host their services with the major cloud providers from the USA. So it’s important to ask for more specific details.
- Server in Germany doesn’t mean the data is save. If the servers are operated by US-cloud-providers, the USA still has access to them.
- Even if the server is operated by an EU company within the EU, software from the USA can still create a dependency. If, for example, Windows is used, Microsoft can not only collect data (and has already been sued for its extensive data collection), but could also distribute certain malicious functions or cut off EU customers’ access to updates.
How do we become more independent?
- Using open source software makes it possible to continue developing the software on our own in case of an emergency. European companies can also be paid to contribute to further development, as Germany does with KDE.
- Instead of specialized cloud services, such as Google Firestore or AWS Lambda, you can use more flexible systems, such as Kubernetes, which are offered by many cloud providers, making it easy to switch providers.
- It may also make sense to use multiple providers so that if one goes down, the other provider continues to run and a complete outage is avoided.
- Decentralized systems like the Fediverse make it possible to participate in the network using one’s own infrastructure, without a central authority deciding who can participate. Closed networks based in the U.S., such as Facebook, Twitter, or LinkedIn, must comply with U.S. law. In the Fediverse, an instance in Germany follows German law and rules based on local values.
- Switching between services (like restoring backups) should be tested from time to time to ensure that it actually works and to eliminate any obstacles.
Update 2026-11-20 14:30: The German show FunFacts in the episode with Linus Neumann also has spoken about this topic (on YouTube or PeerTube)